# 14. Returning at the merge gate

> I read the evidence, then decide what ships.

Lesson 14 of 27. Part 4 of 6: Judge the result. Source: https://chiefofagents.si/lessons/returning-at-the-merge-gate

## The lesson

Review finishes before the work reaches me. One pull request tells one story I can trace. Changes that would make review unclear get separate pull requests.

The checks have to be green on the exact commit proposed for merge, not on an earlier one.

I do not replay every step the agents took. I review the evidence and decide.

## How I do it

The real evidence pack shown on this site says it plainly: PASS, 11 of 11 checks, 17 of 17 tests, and "Not done here: merge, production database changes."

## The rule

Make the thing you review small, single-purpose and tied to one exact commit.
